My Last Five Girlfriends
Naomi Harris, Brendan Patricks, Cécile Cassel, Jane March, Kelly Adams, Edith Bukovics
Based on the writings of Alain de Botton, an intelligent romcom that rings truer than most...
Wearing its jumble of styles defiantly on its sleeve, Julien Kemp’s romantic comedy spares no imaginative expense in pursuing a visual replication of the documentary/scientific/autobiographical/fictional meld that characterises its source text, Alain de Botton’s novel Essays in Love. The budget may have been smaller than the ambition at play here, but the film’s cheerful mix of Michel Gondry-style visual experimentation with a High Fidelity-style effort to give the male perspective on love makes for a hugely likeable and engaging new take on the romcom – and a low-budget film that sees no necessity to cloak itself in murky social realism. Rather, with its dry humour, lo-fi special effects and quirkily obsessive analyses of everyday phenomena, Kemp’s film rather resembles The Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, and takes on an explanatory remit only slightly less daunting. On the verge of suicide, a young man, Duncan (Brendan Patricks), gropes for some meaningful assessment of the demoralising and emasculating events that have led him to this desperate pass – his experiences, in other words, with women. Did a grand universal plan lie behind his apparently random meeting with dizzy Wendy (Kelly Adams)? Just why did she keep shuttling between him and her ex? Why did Duncan then keep switching personalities to please gorgeous Olive (Jane March)? And why was it so necessary for him to be straight with Rhona (Cécile Cassel) concerning what he thought of her new shoes, thus hurting her feelings and ultimately killing off the relationship? Duncan’s meanderings through his own fraught romantic past are given entertaining visual form by way of the extended metaphor of a fairground, with his time in each woman’s world illustrated by a rollercoaster ride. Elsewhere, animated sequences, special guest appearances (by, for instance, Johnny Ball, calculating the probability of a particular meeting) and sudden interjections by inanimate objects give idiosyncratic expression to Duncan’s somewhat obsessive mindset. If his niggling self-absorbtion might make it only too apparent why most of his relationships crash and burn, his journey to greater self-knowledge is both endearing and instructive; and the film’s analysis of all the commonplace hypocrisies, contradictions, booby traps and confidence tricks encountered in dating will yield no shortage of sighs of recognition.
2009 Archive
Festival Diary: June
Find Films By Strand
EIFF is split into Strands. Use them to help find your films.
Event Search
Suggest-o-tron
Use this fun gadget to help you navigate the Festival programme and find your festival feet.
Start Suggest-o-tron
Comments
Login or Register to post / report comments
#1 Mike Hall / Monday 13 July, 2009 / 18:53 GMT
The film is crammed with witty and ingenious ideas – the Barbie doll vignette to summarise the ‘girl on a plane’ back-story is inspired, as is the Theme Park concept of a different ride for each girlfriend. Nice. The cameos are perfectly-pitched, in particular Michael Sheen and Johnny Ball, and the effervescent Vitamin C tablet fake ending was equally well-judged. The pace is fast and there’s little, if any, slack in the tight script – indeed, if I had a minor grumble, it would be that I felt the film would have benefitted from a little more time spent on character development of girlfriends 1-4.
Effective as a comedy on a number of levels, it even managed to slot in some painful relationship truisms – the ‘cereal box’ effect at the start of a relationship, yet another clever idea – that had the audience chuckling in knowing appreciation.
It left me wanting more, and I hope that commercial success beckons, because this film thoroughly merits it. 7/10 (which is admittedly a bit mean, and more down to me not really liking the genre).