Awful

This was hilarious.

The first fifteen minutes of this film looked promising, but as soon as Adrien Brody appeared it became apparent that the dialogue was going to be nothing more than a series of the worst movie cliches strung together for an hour and a half. It was so bad, the entire cinema was in stitches at a couple of points. Worth watching though, just for the priceless moment when the backstory of Adrien Brody's character is told in flashback... "I explained everything". Beautiful.

And since when did BoSelecta become a serial killer?

Did Adrian Brodie bother reading the script beforehand? The terrible dialogue kept the audience entertained at least.

If the rumours are be to believed, Brody (who was also one of the film's executive producers) re-wrote most of his own dialogue and weighed in on other "creative" decisions. I thought he was by far the weakest link in what was otherwise an unremarkable but watchable enough thriller. As a long-term Argentophile, this didn't even come close to the dizzy heights of his best work, but at least I was entertained.

I saw Giallo last night. It was, well, just terrible. The plot was so thin as to be invisible, the villian (a sort of mutant Rocky - played it seems by Adrien Brody in latex) was laughable and the whole thing was unintentionally hilarious. Argento has apparently disowned it so it's possibly not his fault it's as bad as it is. Still my mate that I saw it with is possibly his biggest fan and he was abosulutely raging at it. I was very disappointed in it and I didn't really have any expectations not being a big Argento fan (I'd previously only seen Suspiria and Mother of Tears thought the former was great and the latter daft but fun). I'm thinking that straight to DVD is about the best that can be hoped for this.

I'm still raging at how utterly terrible this film was. Incredibly un-Argento AND un-Giallo and most definitely un-interesting. Dull dull dull. Wake up Dario..........

Laugh-out-loud! How on earth did this make the Best of the Fest?

If this was a spoof, and to be honest with a reputable director and cast putting out a poorly shot and badly acted movie how can it not be, it was a work of utter genius. If Tarintino had done this everyone would be saying how amazing it was, and quite frankly it was still far superior to Death Proof. I saw this as part of best of the fest and it was the only film I was at that day to get a round of applause at the end. Was there a Q&A session for this after one of the screenings? That would have been worth seeing.

Absolutely terrible, fairly indicative of anything Lisa lambert is involved with! Utterly utterly awful!